返回总目录
Response to Misha'al Al-Kadhi: The Life of Muhammad
A response to Chapter 10
The Life of Muhammad
Muslims believe that Muhammad is the last of the prophets,
who brought forth the full and final revelation of God to
mankind.
"We sent you not (O Muhammad), but as a Mercy for all
creatures."
[There is no doubt that Muhammad believed he was called of
God, but the circumstances around this "call" need some
explanation. Muhammad himself said of the angel,
"He choked me with the cloth until I believed that I
should die. Then he released me and said: Recite!" When
he hesitated, he received 'twice again the repeated harsh
treatment'. This seems to many an unusual form of coercion,
unlike a gracious and merciful God Muslims claim Allah to
be, as well as contrary to the free choice they claim he
has granted his creatures.
Muhammad lacked faith in what he was preaching and
did not really believe in his heart what Allah was
revealing to him. At one point, he believed he was
demon-possessed. For example, why should he feel as
if he were being strangled if it was a good God that
wanted to give him a message? After 23 years or so
of preaching, Muhammad could only say 'I do not know
what will be done with me or with you (... those who
followed his teaching)' (46:9). Can you imagine
that?
Also clouding the alleged divine origin of his message is
the fact that after this there was a long period of silence,
which according to some accounts lasted 3 years, during
which time Muhammad fell into the depths of despair, feeling
forsaken by God, and even entertaining thoughts of suicide.
These characteristics strike many as
uncharacteristic of a divine call] (The Crescent in the
Light of the Cross, Norman L. Geisler & Abdul Saleeb,
published by Baker Books, copyright 1993, pp. 146-
169).
Now let's take a look at violence in the life of Muhammad.
Many Muslims do not like reading about the violence in
Islam as they believe this is a misrepresentation.
But can they ignore their history? Muhammad
not only commanded wars, but was also involved in person.
In regard to religious tolerance, the only place any
Muslim can confidently point to in the Quran is surah
2:256 which says in part, "Let there be no compulsion in
religion". But we all know this statement
was made at the early stage of Muhammad's mission, when
he was just settling down in Medina. Such
an attitude was necessary in order to get the co-operation
of the Jewish tribes and Christians who were in the majority
in Medina. Muhammad said he believed in all
the Jewish prophets, and that he had not brought any new
religion but the very things that the old prophets of
Israel had preached.
In the Meccan messages of Muhammad, there are positive and
friendly statements about Jews, Christians, and the
Scriptures. Here the prophet expects a warm
welcome from the Arabian Jews and Christians concerning
his divine commission and proclamation of God's unity.
(2:62, 29:46, 5:50, 10:94).
However, as time went on and Muhammad was rejected by the
majority of Jews and Christians as an imposter, Muhammad's
attitude toward these people and the scriptures shifted
dramatically. And the change in his
disposition becomes clearly reflected not only in the
later verses of the Quran and his treatment of the Jews,
but also to a great extent in Islamic theology and
culture. (5:54, 3:85, 5:85, 9:29, 2:42, 3:71,78,
4:46, 2,78,85).
At that time, he did not have enough people to wage any
war. When, however, he had raised enough
military manpower, he began to launch out against those
he suspected did not believe in his religion. Speaking
as an oracle of Allah, Muhammad commanded true muslims
to:
(9:29) "fight those who believe not in Allah nor the last
day nor acknowledge the religion of truth".
The Quran says to fight Buddhists, Jews, and Christians,
and whoever else doesn't believe in Islam.
(9:5) "fight and slay the pagans wherever ye find them,
and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for
them ... but IF they repent, and establish regular
prayers, and pay zakat ... THEN open the way for them".
The Quran even ADVOCATES forced
conversions. IF ... THEN.
Slay them until they accept Islam ...
(9:29) "fight them until (let me repeat ... UNTIL)
they pay the Jizya". In other words, if
they don't pay the Jizya, keep fighting them.
Muhammad was commanded by Allah to make sure that
Islam prevails over all the other religions (61:9).
The Quran even orders Muslims not to take Jews and
Christians as friends (5:51). One begins
to wonder how there can be any peace in the world
when muslims are given this command.
The Quran orders muslims to be obedient in killing
in order to spread Islam (4:74) "let those fight in
the cause of Allah ... whether he is slain or gets
victory". Allah loves those who fight
in battle array (61:4). Muslim soldiers
who sacrificed their lives for the cause of Islam
are even awarded a paradise filled with virgins
(3:157-158; 22:58-59; 56:10-22,35-38; etc).
After Muhammad fled to Medina, life soon became
difficult for these settlers economically, and they
had to survive. Muhammad therefore felt
that he had to take revenge on the Meccan merchants
for the hostility he had suffered in Mecca.
But because of their ethnic affliliation, many of the
Muslims did not see why they should attack and loot
their own tribesman in order to survive or because of
a religion. But a revelation came to Muhammad
from Allah to justify this first mobilization for
Jihad. And so, in surah (2:216), we read,
"Jihad is ordained for you and you disliked it, and it
may be that you dislike a thing which is good for
you ...".
Among the first blood sheb by Muhammad's followers in
Medina was that of a poetess, Asma, daughter of
Merwan and wife of Yazid bin Zaid. According
to Ibn Ishaq in his monumental work "Sirat ar-Rasul",
edited by Ibn Hisham and translated into English by
A. Guillaume under the title "The Life of Muhammad",
Mrs. Asma Yazid had composed and popularized some poems
to ridicule the people of Medina for following a man
who had slain 49 of his own tribesmen at Badr and looted
their caravan in order to establish a religion.
This woman was stabbed on her bed. About three other
poets who could not be silent had their necks face
the sharp edge of the Islamic sword and soon lost their
heads. One of them was Abu 'Afrak.
Another poet (and soldier), Abbas, was to face a similar
judgement. It was after the battle of
Honain. The problem arose as to the way
Muhammad shared the booty. Abbas, said to be
a lukewarm convert, grumbled about Muhammad's arithmetic
of sharing the booty. Muhammad overheard him
and said with a smile, "Take that man from here and cut
out his tongue" (Khan, M. Ebrahim. "Anecdotes from
Islam", Sh. Muhammad Ashraf, Lahore (1960), p.20).
Immediately following the Battle of Badr, Muhammad's
prestige increased greatly. Relying on his
newly elevated status, Muhammad launched the systematic
elimination of his opponents in Medina, which in
Muhammad's mind had always posed a real threat to the
stability of the Islamic community. This
extermination involved the assassination of some poets
who had satirized the prophet in verse, and also the
expulsion of one of the three Jewish tribes from
Medina.
Barely one year after the defeat at Uhud, Muhammad
expelled the second Jewish tribe from Medina and
confiscated all their properties. Shortly
after the seize of Medina, Muhammad attacked the
last Jewish tribe based on the suspicion that they
had plotted with the Meccan enemies against Muslims.
Unlike the previous two Jewish tribes that had been
simply expelled from the city, this time all the men
of the tribe were put to death and the women and
children were sold into slavery.
Now to the present day: Even though Ayatollah Khomeini
belonged to the Shiite sect of Islam, he was generally
regarded as an exemplary muslim of our time.
Following the steps of the prophet of Allah in
establishing an Islamic state, Khomeini slaughtered
more people during the first few years of his reign
than were killed during all the years of his predecessor,
Shah Muhammad Reza Pahlavi. After all the
massacres of non-Muslims in Persia (present day Iran),
Khomeini said: "In Persia no people have been killed so
far - only beasts!"
On another occasion, this servant of Allah said: "The
purest joy in Islam is to kill and be killed for Allah".
Early in 1984, Khomeini was quoted as saying: "In order
to achieve the victory of Islam in the world, we need to
provoke repeated crises, restore value to the idea of death
and martyrdom. If Iran has to vanish, that is not important.
The important thing is to engulf the world in crises".
From our studies of the Quran so far, was
Khomeini sounding un-quranic or un-allahic?
In surah (4:89), Allah commands that any person who
leaves Islam or encourages others to do so, should
be seized and slain. That is the main reason
why muslims are very much afraid to being converted
to christianity in a muslim country.
In Islamic countries, it is lawful for a muslim to
convert a christian to Islam, but illegal, and in fact,
a serious crime for a christian to attempt to convert
a muslim to Christianity. In some countries,
the christian preachers may face a death penalty.
Christianity is blasphemed by all true Muslims today
and without any consequence. On the other
hand, you cannot say anything bad about Islam without
fear of death. Take Salman Rushdie as one
example. The woman from India (who just
spoke against Islamic law) is in fear of her life.
Then we have that 12 year old boy from Pakistan.
They were going to execute him on suspicion that he
said something bad about Muhammad. And then you
have the persecution of Christians by Muslims in Africa,
Indonesia, and the Phillipines as other examples.
I hear about these attrocities from the missionaries
that report back. The muslims that do these
things are not fanatical. They are just
following the precepts of the Quran.
According to surah (9:19), there are three things that
attract more rewards than all others. These
are: belief in Allah, belief in the last day, and
jihad. These three supersede many other good deeds
in Islam.
Saying anything bad about Muhammad invokes a strong
response in Muslims. It has even resulted in the
death or imprisonment of some Christians throughout
the world. Its a good thing that Christians
do not respond in kind when Muslims blaspheme Christ
and the Bible with their attacks.
Since Al-Kadhi put large emphasis on the letters
Muhammad supposedly wrote to various emperors, please
also see the article on
Muslim tradition on Heraclius' response to Muhammad's invitation.
About Muhammad
The Rebuttal to "What Did Jesus Really Say?"
Answering Islam Home Page