返回总目录
The Islamic View of Creation
The Islamic View of Creation
CREATION OF MAN
In the 19th century Charles Darwin put forward a theory that man came
into being through a long process of evolution and not all of a sudden
in one stroke as stated in the Bible. He concluded that the
evolutionary process which produced man in his present form probably
took millions of years. The second main point in Darwin's theory is
that man evolved from lower forms of animal life. In the beginning
there existed only small types of animals which during the course of
time were followed by larger and larger ones. Eventually one of these
kinds of animals developed into man as we know him but it has now
become extinct although it can be maintained that a better form of that
animal, the missing linkage is represented by the monkey. This theory
is based on the fact that ancient human skeletons which have been
unearthed in various places show remarkable differences from one
age to another in the size or structure of the bones or skull. This is
taken to indicate that there has been a slow development and progress
of the species from era to era. It is also argued that the embryo in
the womb, at different stages of its development, successively
resembles a number of lower animals such as a rabbit, fish or something
else. This is taken to furnish ground for the conclusion that the
stages which the embryo passes through represent, so to say, the stages
which man has passed through from a lower animal to that of a human
being. A further argument advanced in support of the theory of
evolution is that there are a number of similarities which seem to
indicate that man and these lower animals are one and the same thing
and that the structure of the human body is not an exclusive feature of
the human species as it has evolved from the bodies and structures
ures such as those shared by the apes.
The second point in Darwin's theory was that man and apes developed
from a common link which is now extinct. The basis of the argument is
that certain kinds of monkeys have a striking resemblance to man.
Darwin surmised that in this chain one link is missing as indicated by
the gulf which should not have otherwise existed between man and the
apes on one side, and the apes and animals on the other. Since there is
a remarkable degree of similarity between man and the apes, and since,
on the other hand, a gulf seems to separate the apes from other
animals, it appears that some link has disappeared which bridged this
gulf---the link from which man and the apes have evolved during the
process of time.
Haeckel, after Darwin, was of the opinion that the missing link was an
animal which he called Lipotylu which has become extinct leaving no
trace behind it. If this animal, or its remains, could be found then
the missing link which breaks the chain of continuity would come to
hand and leave no vagueness or uncertainty about the theory of
evolution. Thinkers of this kind believe that the gorilla and
chimpanzee stand in the line of human ancestry.
Darwin's theory was subjected to criticism by many thinkers who pointed
out that the wide gulf separating man from the apes precluded a common
ancestry for both. In these differences, however, Huxley found further
support for the theory of evolution. He pointed out that the difference
found between different kinds of monkeys was greater than the one found
between man and the apes. In spite of the wide differences between
varieties of monkeys, all were taken and accepted as monkeys. Huxley
argued that when differences between different species of monkeys were
so wide then why could not man have also traveled a long way from the
ape during the course of time? He concluded, therefore, that this gulf
did not stand against evolution but on the other hand tended to support
it.
More recent research which is supported by Professor Jones and
Professor Osborne, tends to conclude that although man has developed
through an evolutionary process he branched off from other animals at a
much earlier period; and during that time he developed on independent
exclusive lines as compared with other animals. In other words, man did
not branch off from some kind of ape, as Darwin believed, but a long
time before that during the development of animal life.
Archaeologists and anthropologists have found that human civilization
has passed through very distinct stages. In the Stone Age man took his
first step towards culture and civilization. Since that time he had
evolved into a state of only the most rudimentary human existence and,
in contrast with other forms of animal life, he did not have the
advantage of claws and fangs, he used stones as weapons for offense and
defense. Then came the Bronze Age when man made use of this metal.
This was followed by the iron age. As a result of excavations
archaeologists are agreed that all the stages of his life man has been
a bearer of culture of one kind or another.
QURAN ON THE CREATION OF MAN
First I would like to refer to the following passage from the Holy
Quran:
What is the matter with you that you hope not for greatness and wisdom
from Allah? And He has created you in different forms and different
conditions. See you not how Allah has created seven heavens in perfect
harmony, and has placed the moon, therein a light and made the sun a
lamp? And Allah has caused you to grow out of the earth as a good
growth. Then will He cause you to return, thereto, and He will bring
you forth a new bringing forth. (71:14-19)
A close paraphrase of this passage would be:
O you human beings! What is the matter with you that you fail to
understand that Allah does not do anything unless there is wisdom and
purpose underlying it? You yourselves are not ready to accept the
assumption that you do things with no aim or purpose in view. Why do
you therefore assume that Allah, the Most Wise and All Knowing does
things without purpose? Why do you jump to the thoughtless conclusion
that He created man with no purpose in view? Why do you fail to grasp
the evident truth that your creation has not been the result of a
sudden meaningless impulse? It was the result of wise planning and
deliberate execution in a succession of stages from one point to
another. Do you not see that Allah has created the seven heavens in
perfect harmony with each other and similarly the sun and the moon?
Also that the earth was one of the stages through which you passed in a
process of slow growth to the point of perfection?
This is the description of the origin and emergence of man given in the
Quran. The law of evolution working in the universe which Europe claims
to have discovered was clearly defined in the Holy Quran more than
fourteen hundred years ago that man was not created in an instant in
the form in which he is today. God did not make a model of clay and
breathed life into it to become the first man. No! Man has reached his
present stage after passing through many intermediary stages. Man
originated from and on this earth---Allah caused you to grow out of the
earth as a good growth.
It is particularly distressing to note, however, that the present day
popular Muslim belief has lost sight of the two crucial points that
man's creation and emergence did not take place in an instant. He was
created from the earth and on the earth. Popular Muslim belief has come
to have it that man was created in paradise from where he was put down
on earth. It is also believed by a large section of Muslims that God
has a bag of souls which, from time to time, He releases singly to
become human beings. In view of the prevalence of such foolish fancies
that the popular Muslim mind, through some irony, is peculiarly bent
upon holding views contrary to the clear teachings of the Holy Quran.
The Quran tells us that the creation of man took place in gradual
stages, the underlying wisdom being that through this slow development
defects should be eliminated from his constitution and nature. The
gross ignorance of the views held by some Muslim religious leaders may
be gaged from the following. Maulvi Syed Sarwar Shah, a prominent
member of the Ahmadiyya Movement and companion of the Promised Messiah,
used to relate that one of his teachers once said that the explanation
for one man being handsome and another ugly, and yet another middling,
is that at the time God decided to make man He awarded a contract to
the angels for carrying out the job fixing a daily quota which had to
be fulfilled. The angels started kneading the clay well and shaping
from it nice and handsome figures. They worked steadily, without hurry,
until noon giving careful attention to each piece. After a while they
found that they were lagging behind the quota fixed and began to work
only with the idea of completing it. They ceased paying careful
artistic attention to their work with the result that the beings formed
during the first spell of their work were very attractive while those
formed in the early part of the afternoon were middling. As the
afternoon wore on the angels realized with dismay that they were still
lagging far behind the quota for the day so they threw all care to the
wind. They hurriedly shaped a figure from the clay with a finger-poke
to make the mouth and two pokes to make the eyes. No wonder these
ungainly dented figures could not be compared with those made during
the first spell of work.
This example shows how, through ignorance, unwarranted beliefs among
Muslims, Christians, Jews and others have turned beautiful truths into
distressing caricatures and spurious myths.
FIRST STAGE
The next point revealed by the Quran in connection with the creation of
man is that the first stage was a condition of non-existence. A
controversial subject. The view of the Arya Samajists is that matter
from which the universe has been shaped, is eternal. God did no more
than to bring the soul to matter together into a close relationship and
so man was created. This belief is repudiated by the Quran which
teaches that matter is not eternal but it is a creation of God and that
man was created. God says in the Holy Quran:
Does not man remember that We created him before, when he was naught? (19:68)
Human birth now takes place from the seed of the male. This verse
refers to the first original creation of the species, or the first man.
it should be carefully noted that the Quran does not say that existence
was created from non-existence. It says that prior to the stage when
matter and other things came into being, there was a stage when nothing
existed. We say that a chair can be made from a piece of wood; or we
say that a chain can be made from a piece of iron. Here we have matter
in one form which can be utilized to make another article. Atheists
often raise the objection that it is not possible to shape out anything
from nothing. This, however, is not what is meant by the Quran. What is
meant is that prior to the creation of the universe there was a stage
when nothing existed. Then came creation and the creation of man. God
has not given knowledge to man as to how this came about, possibly
because it is beyond the comprehension of man to grasp. If man could
visualize how creation took place then he would be in a position to
create man himself.
SECOND STAGE
It appears from the Holy Quran that the second stage in the creation of
man was a state of existence when the human body was there but the
brain or its active faculties which distinguish a human being from the
lower animals were not operative and active as they came to be later.
There was, so to say, a human body which was not yet a human being or,
in other words, there was the physical human body minus the evolved and
perfected human brain or mind. We are not in a position to say whether
in this state he was a kind of rock formation or a kind of plant.
We can say, however, that he was not yet an animal. The Quran says:
There has certainly come upon man a period of time when he was not a
thing spoken of. In other words, there has been a stage in the history
of man when it was not madhkur, i.e., it was not aware of itself,
lacked consciousness at the time and was not capable of recognition. He
was a form of being without consciousness and intelligence, not aware
of himself or of other things.
THIRD STAGE
The third stage in the evolution of man was reached when he attained to
a state of being where the production of the species began to take
place through the seed of the male planted in the body of the female
through sexual intercourse. From this point onwards occurs the almost
infinite variety of individual human temperaments. Among animals there
are varieties not characterized by sex. God says in the Quran that a
stage came in the course of the evolution of man when he developed into
an animal characterized by sex, divided into males and females, when
his procreation began to take place through the seed of the male which
is a characteristic of the higher forms of animal life. His procreation
began to occur from a nutratin amshajin, from the male sperm drop
embracing a combination of a number of elements. God says in the Holy
Quran:
Indeed: We have created man from a mingled sperm-drop, that We might try
him, so We made him hearing, seeing. From this stage his procreation
began to be compounded from many elements because his role in the
universe was to be many sided which necessitated that he should possess
a wide range of qualities.
FOURTH STAGE
The fourth stage came when the human brain reached perfection and
characterized by a highly developed form of awareness and intelligence.
From having the capacity of hearing and seeing which are qualities
also to be found in the lower animals, he became capable of exercising
his intelligence to a point where, through a sustained spirit of
inquiry and search, inference and invention came within the range of
his faculties. Here he rose one very distinct step higher than the
other forms of animal life, an animal capable of sustained thought and
speech.
These links in the chain of the evolution of man are the initial links
of the various stages, The intervening periods between the emergence of
these links have not been clearly brought out by the Quran for it is
not a scientific treatise on the subject. The Quran refers to these
matters which were necessary for bringing out a point of moral
spiritual truth, leaving the filling in of the gaps to the human mind.
We glean from other passages in the Quran that there are also other
links in the chain of human evolution:
And Allah created you from dust, then from a sperm-drop, then he made
you pairs.
Elsewhere the Quran says: 'And Allah caused you to grow from the earth,
a good growth ', while here it is said: 'Allah created you from dust,
then from a sperm-drop'. The remaining links have been omitted, till He
made you pairs. i.e., a being capable of living in social units the
point from which emerges what we call civilization and culture, with a
system and order of life.
The meaning of Azwaj used in the Arabic text of the verse which I have
just quoted does not mean division into male and female because that
point has already been covered in the mention of creation by a
sperm-drop. Then he made you pairs, coming after sperm-drop has to be
interpreted to mean something beyond the emergence of sex. In Arabic
the word zauj also means kind, variety or complimentary groups; and
this is the meaning implied here. When the human mind fully developed
and a variety of temperaments emerged, individuals began to evince
leanings towards or away from certain other individuals. This gave rise
to the emergence of social units on this or that basis such as family
groups or combination of certain individuals well disposed towards each
other.
The evolution of man may be summed up by saying that at first man was
only a clod of earth or some kind of rock formation. After some
intermediary stages which the Quran has not mentioned, man reached a
stage where he became a kind of animal growth divided into male and
female and procreating through sexual intercourse. Again the Quran
leaves out some intermediary stages until man emerges as a social being
divided into several groups as a result of which there sprung up a
variety of mental, physical or economic affiliations. This is the point
where the story of human civilization begins.
Among the stages of the evolution of man is when water mingled with the
particular dust, clod of earth or rocky substance. This mingling of the
dry clod with water which resulted in a kind of life being born in it
is mentioned in the Quran:
And We made from water every living thing... (21:31)
He Who has made perfect everything He has created. and He began the
creation of man from clay. (32:8)
The word in the Arabic text for clay is teen which means earth mixed
with a quantity of water which becomes adhesive. According to the
Quran, therefore, human life originated in a substance which was a
mixture of earth and water which, in the course of time, developed into
man. In the fore-going verses we are told that an early initial stage
in the evolution of man was when he was given a particular form from
wet earth. That was followed by a stage when man began to be procreated
through function of the sex organs of the male and female of his
species. In the words of the Holy Quran:
Then He made His progeny from an extract of an insignificant fluid. (32:9)
Did We not create you from an insignificant fluid, and we placed it in
a safe place? (77:22)
These verses indicate very clearly that man's origin in dry earth or
rock was one stage from which step by step he passed through a stage
when it was mixed with water causing the development of a rudimentary
form of life which later on began to procreate through the functioning
of the sex organs which had developed in the male and female. All these
stages represent different periods of time the duration of which can at
best be only vaguely conjectured or imagined.
The Holy Quran mentions a general principle with regard to the creation
of man:
And that with thy Lord is the final judgment; and that it is He Who
makes people laugh and makes them weep; and it is he Who causes death
and gives life; and that He creates the pairs, male and female, from a
sperm-drop when it is emitted; and that it is for Him to bring forth
the second creation. (53:43-48)
CONCLUSIONS
From these verses of the Quran which I have quoted emerge the following
conclusions:
( 1 ) The material from which man has been created is not eternal. It
was created by God.
(2) Man's creation involved an evolutionary process extending over a
long period of time. He was not created in a moment.
(3) Man was created from an origin of his own species. It is not
correct that he evolved from a species of monkeys or apes which is the
theory advanced by Darwin.
(4) One of the evolutionary stages through which he passed was
something akin to stone or rock.
(5) He next passed through a stage of animal life but intelligence had
not yet developed in him although he moved about, ate and drank like
other animals.
(6) He became an intelligent being able to speak and communicate.
(7) In his final stage he devised a system of life and started on the
road to civilization and culture. Instead of each individual living for
himself, as is the case with other and lower animals, he began to work
in co-operation with others of his species evolving a system and law of
life.
Courtesy of Mr. Zia Shah, zshah@ix.netcom.com.
June 6, 1995
THE ORIGIN OF LIFE
The Quran provides a clear cut answer to the question: At what
point did life begin? In this section, I shall set forth the
verses of the Quran in which it is stated that the origins of
life are aquatic. The first verse also refers to the formation
of the universe:
Do not the Unbelievers see that the heavens and
the earth were joined together, then We clove
them asunder and We got every living thing out
of water. [21:30]
The notion of 'getting something out of something else' does
not give rise to any doubts. The phrase can equally mean that
every living thing was made of water (as its essential compone-
nt) or that every living thing originated in water. Life is in
fact of aquatic origin and water is the living component of
all living cells. Without water, life is not possible. When
the possibility of life on another planet is discussed, the first
question is:
Is there a sufficient quantity of water to support life?
Modern data leads us to think that the oldest living beings probably
belonged from the vegetable kingdom: Algae have been found that date
from the pre-Cambrian period, the time of the oldest known lands.
Organisms belonging to the animal kingdom probably appeared slightly
later: They too came from the sea.
The words translated here as 'water' is in fact 'ma', which means
both water in the sky and water in the sea, or any kind of liquid.
In the first meaning, water is the element necessary to all vegetable
life:
[God is the One Who] sent water down from the sky
and thereby We brought forth pairs of plants each
separate from the other. [20:53]
This is the first reference to a 'pair' of vegetables; we shall
cause to return to this notion later. In the second meaning, which
refers to any kind of liquid, the words is used in its indeterminate
form to designate the substance at the basis of the formation of all
animal life.
God created every animal from water. [24:45]
Thus the statement in the Quran on the origins of life, whether
referring to life in general, the element that gives to birth to the
plants in the soil, or the seed of animals, are all strictly in
accordance with modern scientific data. None of the myths on the
origins of life that abounded at the time the Quran was communicated
to man are mentioned in the text.
Reference: What is the Origin of man?; The Answers of Science and
the Holy Scriptures, By Dr. Maurice Bucaille, Translated from the French by
Alastair D. Pannell and the Author, Second Edition, Revised. Publisher: SEGHERS, 6 Place Saint-Sulpice, 75006 PARIS.
courtesy of Mr. Ali Abbas.
August 1, 1995